As Philly goes, so goes Chester County?

In this week of HS graduations, why you need to be concerned about Philly’s schools

By Mike McGann, Editor, The Times

UTMikeColLogoOut here in Chester County, we’ve been relatively insulated — we think — from the collapse of the Philadelphia Public Schools. Maybe you’ve seen some of the recent discussion about all extra curricular activities, even sports, being cut from the public schools. My guess is that most folks around here shrug and say, “that’s why we don’t live there.”

Except…for decades now, people in Philadelphia and other cities around the state said the same thing and moved. And where did they move?

Out here.

And they keep moving out here. Not to blame “them” — you can’t blame folks for wanting a better life and better schools for their kids.

But it does mean higher taxes, crowded roads and yet another delightful Toll Brothers (evidently, Chadds Ford encompasses surprisingly large swaths of land between Philly and Lancaster) development coming to your area. As we continue to bleed our cities to death, largely by killing off their educational systems, we end up paying two or three dollars for every dollar we save. Add in the environmental impact — in the coming years the term “MS4” will be used to explain potentially double-digit local property tax increases from your municipalities — and the loss of our county’s essential character and starving our cities is saving us so much money we’re going broke.

To be sure, the schools in Philadelphia, like those in Chester-Upland and other urban districts, have been mismanaged and government leaders in those places deserve, rightly, some blame. But allowing these school districts to strangle as is happening in Philadelphia — largely because of the spike in pension costs — isn’t just bad for people there, but for people here, too.

Virtually everything that people hate about Chester County from sprawl to traffic to high taxes has roots in allowing — and in some cases among our local legislative delegation, aiding and abetting — the slow demise of Philadelphia’s schools. The regional population of the Delaware Valley hasn’t increased much, yet counties like Chester have seen explosive growth — as folks left Philadelphia, largely in search of better schools.

But if we in suburbia don’t raise our voices, nothing will change and we’ll just seem more traffic, more sprawl and higher taxes and wonder whatever happened to “our Chester County.”

This week, on Wednesday, concerned parents and educators will be rallying in Harrisburg to fight for Philly’s schools. One hopes that our Chester County legislators hear the calls loud and clear and do what is needed. Not just because it is the right thing to do — and it is — but to protect their constituents, our schools and our communities.

* * *

Since messing up Philadelphia is not nearly ambitious enough of a goal for our state legislature and governor,  it’s looking increasingly like the state won’t be able to do anything to help the public pension mess, privatize state liquor sales or fix our crumbling roads and bridges.

Even for this group, that’s an impressive record of abject failure.

And amazingly, we can’t even blame it on partisan politics.

No, it’s not Democrat versus Republican — and let’s be honest, the Democrats have made themselves virtually a non-factor in state government, an impressive accomplishment for a party with a roughly one million voter registration advantage — nope, it’s state representatives versus state senators and an irrelevant governor, Tom Corbett, caught in between. They’re all Republicans and have gummed up the works and made any hope of a solution pointless.

From our “you can’t make this stuff up” category: the state GOP put out a statement this week where Corbett pledges not to allow “low poll numbers” not to get in the way about doing something about pensions, transportation and liquor privatization. What he didn’t say, and it is telling, is that it is the “Gubernator” (Pennsylvania’s public policy love-child equivalent of a blend of Arnold’s Terminator and Gomer Pyle, USMC) doesn’t have much to say about letting his GOP colleagues in the state legislature get in the way of doing pretty much anything. At all.

You see, the state Senate and Corbett want the transportation bill and a boost in wholesale gas taxes (which will mean higher prices at the pump) to pay for roads and bridges. The house? Not so much.

Meanwhile, the house has passed meaningful reform and privatization of the state’s liquor store system, but the senate seems destined to gut, stall and largely wipe out the bill passed by the lower house and backed by Corbett.

The one thing both houses seem to agree on: State Rep. Chris Ross’ pension reform bill — another Corbett initiative — is kind of like a dead groundhog under the porch. It isn’t going anywhere, but the smell is likely to linger for a few more weeks. That may be for the best — the plan is fraught with shaky math, anyhow. One would hope that the next version will use something like the City of Philadelphia’s model for pension privatization, one that uses a hybrid pension plan to slowly transition the pension from defined benefit to defined contribution, a worthy goal, but one that needs to be done sensibly. The proposed Ross plan would do more long-term financial damage than the 2001 pension vote that caused the current mess.

Meanwhile, the standoff between the state house and senate over roads and liquor would be laughable, were it not so important to the state’s future. The failure on pensions falls more into the “pathetic” category.

The petulant “no more taxes, ever” stance of some (ok, most) GOP state house members rings pretty hollow when we look at the state of our roadways and bridges. Should this bill go down, once again the crumbling, rusty bridge on Route 926 over the Brandywine, slated for replacement since at least 1999, won’t make the cut for at least the next couple of years, due to the lack of funds. And yes, funding has been a primary cause for delay in getting the project done for more than a decade, despite the claims of some apologists.

The same will be true for dozens of bridges and roadways that are in pathetic disrepair.

The liquor bill is being held hostage by the senate, where a handful of GOP senators either convinced that booze is immoral or that it would be immoral to stop getting big campaign contributions from those who benefit from the status quo (cough-beer distributors-cough, cough-public unions-cough) appear ready to gut privatization.

As these are both common sense issues: the state shouldn’t be in the booze business and it’s probably bad to have our roads and bridges compare poorly to those in third world nations, this should have been easy to get done with one party in charge.

You’d think. But nope.

* * *


It’s the first week of June and as you might notice on these pages, high school graduations are front and center.

Whether you have a grad or just know one well, it can be a bit of an emotional period.

While my own kids are either long past graduating — my stepsons graduated from Unionville High School in 2006 and 2007 — or far away donning the cap and gown, my twins are members (so far) of the UHS class of 2019 — it’s impossible not to have personal connections to the local graduating class.

We’ve been lucky to write about, interact and get to know a number of 2013 graduates in and around Chester County. I’m impressed at the poise, intelligence and common sense of so many of them, which gives me confidence for the years ahead.

We wish them all well and appreciate how they have offered much to the tapestry that is our community.

If you have a grad in the family, I know the great sense of pride, accomplishment and maybe a few tears you feel right now. If you’re the grad: congratulations, but the adventure is just beginning.


Pin It

Share this post:

Related Posts

One Comment

  1. Our PA pension problems were caused by Wall Street Bankers, not teachers, police or firefighters. SEE
    Death to My Hometown:
    Congress, the Senate and Obama Administration are not at all interested in prosecuting our Wall Street criminal bankers. Maybe the State of New York will. Meanwhile nothing much has changed.

    Wall Street Bankers are busy making $Billions on thin air knowing that will be bailed out the next time too. And our pensions will take another hit.

Leave a Comment